Citizen Musk: Altruistic free speech aspirations aside, purchasing Twitter gave Musk political leverage similar to Rupert Murdoch’s purchases of the New York Post in 1976 and The Wall Street Journal in 2007. And Jeff Bezos bought The Washington Post for $250 million in 2013.
- Musk’s rationale for buying Twitter: He wanted to make it a private company and allow people to speak more freely on the service. “Twitter has extraordinary potential. I’ll unlock it,” Musk wrote in a letter to the board.
- In the case of Musk, he fired key executives, dissolved Twitter's board of directors, and became the sole authority, making executive decisions on a whim.
- Despite initial claims to restore free speech on the platform, Twitter under Musk has deplatformed detractors, banning journalists and competitors.
A rocky start as Musk sinks in: Once the world’s wealthiest person, Musk now owns one of the world’s largest megaphones and has imposed his will on how it operates, essentially giving him the ultimate bully pulpit, which he has exercised with impunity.
- While Musk tried to reassure Twitter’s advertisers that he wouldn’t loosen content moderation policies, reports that sexist and racist slurs exploded on the platform by 500% over the first weekend had advertisers worried.
Mass firings, rehirings, an advertiser exodus, and ad-hoc user bans have punctuated Musk’s ownership of Twitter.
- Earlier this month, Twitter abruptly fired its Trust and Safety Council, established in 2016 to make the platform more civil and safe, while reinstating tens of thousands of previously banned accounts.
- Attempts to win back advertisers did little to stop 50 of Twitter’s top 100 advertisers from leaving the platform.
- Regulators in the EU, France, and Germany voiced concern over journalist account bans and could push forward with investigations on Media Freedom Act violations.
- Musk ran another of his Twitter polls asking followers "Should I step down as head of Twitter?" The voting concluded with 57.5% voting yes, 42.5% voting no. Musk said he is seeking a suitable CEO as he steps back in the near future.
Twitter stumbles, Tesla suffers: Recent SEC filings revealed Musk sold 22 million more shares of Tesla, valued at $3.6 billion. That brings the total amount of Tesla stock that Musk has sold this year to $23 billion, per Insider.
Twitter’s failure to pay office rent and other bills makes imminent bankruptcy more likely. And Musk leveraging Tesla stock to keep Twitter afloat could tank the EV company's value.
- “Elon abandoned Tesla and Tesla has no working CEO,” said Leo Koguan, Tesla’s third-largest individual shareholder. “Tesla needs and deserves to have a full-time CEO.”
Predictions for 2023: Investors prefer stability and control over drama and unpredictability. Musk’s tenure at the helm of Twitter has been chaotic and could erase value of two companies in the coming year.
A reckoning is inevitable, and Elon Musk will have to divert his attention back to Tesla, which is by far the more profitable business. There’s no telling how much damage has been done to Tesla’s value and how long it could take to restore it.
Twitter will continue to lose users at the bottom and advertisers at the top. While it still retains some influence, there is an opportunity for alternative social media apps to offer a safe haven for fleeing users.